Alternative Design

After considering the realistic and design constraints, alternative design options were considered for the soil remediation, embankment design, abutment design, and foundation design of the Monmouth County MA-14 Bridge. For the soil remediation, both preloading and wick drains were considered as a method to accelerate the consolidation of the organic clay layer in the soil profile. Embankment design is governed by consolidation and slope stability, and the slope stability methods considered were geo-textile reinforcement or a retaining wall design. For the abutment design a retaining wall option was considered, which would work in conjunction with a sheet pile bulkhead design. Lastly, considering shallow foundations do not perform well in cohesive soil conditions deep foundations were selected as the only reasonable design. Deep foundation solutions such as driven piles and drilled shafts were assessed for the optimal design option.

Soil Properties

After determining the soil profile, soil properties for each stratum were calculated. For the cohesive layers (C and E), laboratory test results for unit weight, compression ratio, recompression ratio, pre-consolidated stress, and cohesion provided by TerraSense were averaged. For the granular layers (A,B,D,F), the unit weight, angle of friction, bearing capacity, and compression ratio were calculated by empirical graphs using the average SPT value for each individual layer.

 

Stratum

Unit Weight (pcf) Angle of Friction (degrees)  

C’

 

CR

 

RR

Pre-Consolidated Stress (ksf)  

Cohesion (ksf)

A 110 33 68 0.014
B 100.00 31 46 0.022
C 93.82 0.287 0.03 1.6-4.0 0.46
D 120 33 55 0.018
E 119.5 0.119 0.03 21.8 1.76
F 130 39 95 0.011

Watershed Curve Number (CN)

After using Streamstats to determine the watershed area, a .SHP file was saved and uploaded to Web Soil Survey.  The watershed characteristics were transferred and the soil types were determined.  After using the soil types and the land use an overall CN was determined to be 76.

Soil Profile

The team created a soil profile using the selected boring logs explained in the site plan update. The soil was separated into 6 strata. The top layer consisted of fill while the next layer was comprised of loose sand. The largest of the strata was the organic clay which was approximately 60 feet thick located at an elevation of about -10 feet. After the organic clay, a thin layer of sand was present followed by a stiff clay layer. The lowest layer explored was a dense sand layer approximately 95 feet deep.

soil_profile

Site Plan

The team developed a site plan which includes the locations of the boring logs used for the soil profile. A conservative design approach was used while selecting which borings to use for the profile. Of the sixteen boring logs available, eight were located on the westbound side while the other eight were directly across on the eastbound side.  The eight that were chosen for each location along the bridge contain the poorest soil conditions.

site_plan

First Site Visit

On Monday August 24th, our team went to visit the site of the Monmouth County MA-14 Bridge.  With the help of our Industry Advisor, Joseph Strafaci, we were able to examine the structural integrity of the bridge and get a realistic view of the surrounding area.  As a result of this first site visit, our team has a better understanding of the design constraints as well as what improvements should be considered for our final design.

DSC02884   DSC02870   DSC02876   DSC02866   DSC02901